acceleration.jpg Teach Engineering Resources for K12

Hosted by:
National Science Digital Library
National Science Foundation
Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary

Activities may be standalone, or part of lessons or curricular units.

TE Activity: Windy Tunnel

Summary

The purpose of this activity is to demonstrate Bernoulli's Principle as it relates to winged flight. The students will use computers to see the influence of camber and airfoil angle of attack on the lift.

Engineering Connection

Engineers continuously check their designs before they are final. Wind tunnels and computer simulations of wind tunnels enable aerospace engineers to test their wing designs before they build full-size aircraft. By using small-size models and computer simulations, engineers can test the performance of their design in an inexpensive, efficient and safe manner.

Contents

  1. Learning Objectives
  2. Materials
  3. Introduction/Motivation
  4. Procedure
  5. Attachments
  6. Safety Issues
  7. Troubleshooting Tips
  8. Assessment
  9. Extensions
  10. Activity Scaling
  11. References

Grade Level: 5 (4-6) Group Size: 2
Time Required: 50 minutes
Activity Dependency : None
Expendable Cost Per Group : US$ 0
(computer activity)
Keywords: airplanes, lift, symmetry, asymmetry, camber, airfoil, angle of attack, Bernoulli Principle, velocity
Reviews:  Read Reviews  |  Be the First to Write a Review

Related Curriculum

Educational Standards    

  •   Colorado Math
  •   Colorado Science

Learning Objectives (Return to Contents)

After this activity students, should be able to:

  • Define lift.
  • Use the internet to model lift on an airplane wing.
  • Explain the effects that airfoil shape and angle have on lift.
  • Understand angles of attack.
  • Differentiate between a symmetric and asymmetric shape.
  • Know what a proportion is.
  • Interpret math sentences.
  • Use variables in math equations.
  • Tell what Bernoulli's Principle is.

Materials List (Return to Contents)

Each group should have:

Introduction/Motivation (Return to Contents)

If you arm wrestle someone, who wins? Well of course, the person who exerts the most force wins! But, if both "wrestlers" push with the same force, their arms do not move. Lift on airplane wings is somewhat similar. As air flows over the top and bottom of the wing the pressure and velocity of the air change. These changes create lift. But on a symmetric wing, the changes on the top half match the bottom half. If the forces on the top and bottom of the wing are the same, there is no lift. Because the cambered airfoil (the curve in the wing) is not symmetric, the forces on the top and bottom are different — in this case lift is generated.

Can you ever have lift on a symmetric airfoil? Yes, if you raised the nose of the airplane. This would place the wing at an angle. Engineers call this the angle of attack. Now the forces on the top and bottom of the wing are different and will create lift.

The greater the angle of attack, the more lift; however, this only works up to a certain angle. If the angle is too high, the air will not flow smoothly over the airfoil and no lift can be created; the wing will stall, which means it will lose lift.

Engineers often use wind tunnels to see how the air is flowing and if it flows smoothly over a wing. They do this by filling a wind tunnel's air chamber with smoke and allowing that (smoky) air to blow over a model wing. This process also allows them to determine how much drag an airfoil has by the size of the wake (an area whose airflow is not smooth at the trailing edge of the airfoil). Finally, they can also see stall when the air has separated from the wing and actually starts to flow towards the front the airfoil.

Now try out the virtual wind tunnel!

Background on Wind Tunnels

If you cut a wing from its leading (front) edge to its trailing edge (back), the "cutaway" illustrated in the Figure 1 is what you would see. Aeronautical engineers call this an airfoil.

An illustration of two wings which demonstrate airfoil.  The airfoil on the left is symmetric, while the airfoil on the right has camber (curve) and is asymmetric.
Figure 1. Airfoils
click for copyright

The top and bottom halves of the first airfoil are identical — this is referred to as symmetric. The airfoil on the right is not symmetric: its top and bottom halves are different. The difference in the bottom from the top means this airfoil is cambered.

The Four Forces of Flight

The four forces of flight are lift, weight, thrust and drag. Lift and weight are opposites and will counteract one another. Likewise, thrust and drag will counteract one another.

How Does the Bernoulli Principle Create Lift?

The top of a plane's wing is longer than the bottom because it is curved (see Figure 2). This means air will travel faster over the top of the wing than under it. As a result, the air moving over the top has less time to push on the wing, creating less air pressure than air passing below the wing. In the diagram below, the air moving under the wing moves slower and exerts more pressure/force on the wing than does the air moving over the wing. Since there is more force under the wing than above it, the net result is that the wing rises up, creating lift. This principle forms the basis of winged flight.

A colorful diagram shows large, red arrows (representing high air pressure) pushing up on a wing from below, while small, yellow arrows (representing low air pressure) are pushing down on the wing from above.  The result is one large, green arrow, which represents the lifting force, pointing upwards.
Figure 2. How a wing produces lift.
click for copyright

There are flaps on the front and back edges of the wing. During takeoff and landing, pilots extend the flaps on the back edge of the wing. The flaps increase the curve of the wing, which maintain the lift at slower speeds. After takeoff, the pilot retracts (puts back in) the flaps. Engineers continuously test their designs of wings to determine the lift, and in so doing, they must consider the following when testing:

  • The amount of air diverted by the wing is proportional to the speed of the wing and the air density.
  • The vertical velocity of the diverted air is proportional to the speed of the wing and the angle of attack.
  • The lift is proportional to the amount of air diverted times the vertical velocity of the air.
  • The power needed for lift is proportional to the lift times the vertical velocity of the air.

Before the Lesson

With the Students

  1. Discuss Bernoulli's Principle and introduce the concept of lift.
  2. Explain the difference between a symmetric and cambered (asymmetric) airplane wing.
  3. Direct students' attention to the worksheet and website. Have students read the background information silently to themselves. Allow 10 minutes, and discuss the reading.
  4. Have students break into pairs.
  5. Be sure to model the process. Students may find it difficult to grasp how the model runs. The model depicts velocity lines flowing over different wing types. Velocity lines that are close together above the wing demonstrate lift; lines that are the same distance apart above and below the wing demonstrate no lift.

Instructions for Virtual Wind Tunnel

  1. Pick an Airfoil Shape from Column #1.
  2. Pick an Angle Of Attack from Column #2.
  3. Click "Run Tunnel."
  4. Close the window when you are done with this activity.
  5. Have students complete the worksheet. Be sure they try several models to decide which causes the most or least lift.
  6. Be sure to model the process. Students may find it difficult to turn the English sentences into math equations. The worksheet walks students through the process step-by-step.
  7. Discuss with the students that the phrase "proportional to something " means "equal to some number multiplied by something." More specifically we can say "is proportional to" means K times something where K is the constant of proportionality.
  8. Assign Math Worksheet 2 for students to complete for homework. (This worksheet may not be appropriate for lower grades.)

Safety Issues (Return to Contents)

There are no safety issues since this is a computer activity.

Troubleshooting Tips (Return to Contents)

Make sure students understand the directions. Make sure all computers are preset to the appropriate website. Be sure to have students read the background information or go over it as a class.

Pre-Activity Assessment

Discussion Question/Answer: Ask students questions and have them raise their hands to respond. Write answers on the board

  • If you arm wrestle someone, who wins? (Well of course, the person who exerts the most force wins!)
  • What happens if both "wrestlers" push with the same force? (Their arms do not move.)
  • How does this relate to lift? (Lift occurs when the force under a plane is greater than the force pushing down on the plane (weight). This is the same as arm wrestling since the person who exerts the most force pushes the other arm in that direction.)
  • Describe the force of lift and how it affects airplane flight. (The students should understand Bernoulli's Principle — that lift is caused when the air is pushing harder from below the wing than above the wing.)

Activity Embedded Assessment

Worksheet: Have the students record observations and comments on their Windy Tunnel worksheet. After students have finished their worksheet, have them compare answers with their peers. Discuss as a class.

Post-Activity Assessment

Figure drawing/Race: Draw an airfoil on the board (see Figure 1 for sample airfoils). Have two students come to the board and race who can draw (with chalk or whiteboard marker) the top or the bottom of the airfoil the fastest. The student who "wins" completes the drawing (gets to the end of the airfoil) first. Which student was the fastest? Will that airfoil create lift or not?

Activity Extensions (Return to Contents)

A great teacher demo on lift is to throw a Frisbee. The shape of the top of the Frisbee is smooth and air flows over the top faster, creating less pressure. It takes longer for air to flow over the bottom of a Frisbee, thus creating a higher-pressure area that lifts the Frisbee up into the air.

Have students compare airfoil shapes with the wing shapes on different airplanes. Why do different planes have different wing shapes?

Students can research aerospace engineers and how they use lift/drag.

Activity Scaling (Return to Contents)

  • For lower grades: You may want to have the class read the wind tunnel instructions together and ask for questions after they have been read. Also, the math worksheet may not be appropriate. You can walk through the steps of creating a math equation as a class.
  • For higher grades: Use Math Worksheet 2: Windy Tunnel: What Does It Mean?

This activity is adapted from the Society of Women Engineer's Internet Activity Center: http://www.swe.org/iac/LP/wind_01.html

Owner (Return to Contents)

Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado at Boulder

Contributors

Tom Rutkowski, Alex Conner, Geoffrey Hill, Malinda Schaefer Zarske, Janet Yowell

Copyright

© 2004 by Regents of the University of Colorado.
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under a grant from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0226322. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.


Last Modified: April 27, 2006
K12 engineering curriculum K-12 engineering curricula K12 engineering curricula K-12 engineering activities K12 engineering activities K-12 engineering lessons K12 engineering lessons Engineering for children Engineering activities for children K-12 science activities K12 science activities K-12 science lessons K12 science lessons